Island Shores Homes for Sale

Welcome to Island Shores, a picturesque subdivision nestled along the stunning coastline of Florida. This enchanting community is a hidden gem, offering a perfect blend of tranquility and vibrant coastal living. With its lush landscapes and serene waterways, Island Shores is an ideal retreat for those seeking both relaxation and adventure.

The homes for sale in Island Shores are a testament to the area’s charm and elegance. From modern single-family residences to cozy cottages, each property boasts unique architectural styles and thoughtful designs, ensuring that there’s something for everyone. Many of these homes feature spacious open floor plans, gourmet kitchens, and expansive outdoor living spaces, perfect for entertaining guests or enjoying a quiet evening under the stars.

Residents of Island Shores enjoy access to a variety of amenities, including pristine beaches just a short stroll away, scenic parks, and vibrant local shops and restaurants. The community fosters a friendly atmosphere, making it easy to connect with neighbors and create lasting friendships. Whether you’re an outdoor enthusiast, a foodie, or someone who simply enjoys the laid-back Florida lifestyle, Island Shores has it all.

With homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets, this subdivision presents a unique opportunity for potential buyers. Embrace the coastal lifestyle you’ve always dreamed of and discover the beauty of Island Shores today. Don’t miss your chance to be part of this idyllic community, where every day feels like a vacation!

Newest Island Shores Homes for Sale

$549,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Island Shores SubDv.

This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom POOL home is situated in Flood Zone X, meaning flood insurance is not mandatory. It boasts a lovely fenced backyard and is conveniently located near all essential amenities. Recent updates include Hot water heater and dishwasher (2023), New weather head (2023), New turf and firepit with paver patio (2024), New A/C 2025. The home is just a short distance from a kayak launch into Sarasota Bay and directly down 40th Street to the Charles Hegener Memorial Nature Walk. It’s also close to attractions such as Jungle Gardens, the Asolo Theater, Sarasota International Airport, the Ringling Museum of Art, New College, USF, and Downtown Sarasota. Plus, the home did NOT flood during last year’s hurricanes. There are NO deed restrictions. The IBISSA Homeowners Association is voluntary, with an optional annual fee of $50. Great location for Airbnb BRAND NEW POOL PUMP MAY 2026

831 40th Street, North Sarasota

$4,899,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Island Shores SubDv.

A striking fusion of modern architecture, refined craftsmanship, and coastal living, 441 stands as one of Fort Myers Beach’s most exceptional north-end waterfront residences. Located just moments from Times Square with quick access to the Matanzas Pass Bridge, this premier address offers the perfect balance of convenience, privacy, and postcard-worthy surroundings. With the Bay in your backyard just minutes to open water and the beach in your front yard, the lifestyle here is nothing short of extraordinary. Bold curb appeal sets the tone with a wide paver driveway, abundant exterior lighting, and commanding modern lines that create a powerful first impression. Inside, the home’s elevated design showcases full concrete walls and concrete floors throughout, custom plantation shutters, two laundry rooms, and an expansive enclosed lower level in addition to two garages. Architectural resin pecky cypress ceilings, monolithic quartzite slabs, Lauriermax cabinetry, and a curated LED lighting design enrich every room with luxurious texture and ambiance. The gourmet kitchen is both sculptural and functional, featuring a Wolf 6-burner natural gas range, Sub-Zero refrigeration, a hidden walk-in pantry, quartzite surfaces, an integrated barista system, and instant hot water on demand at the kitchen sink. The adjoining bar area is perfectly designed for elevated entertaining with a full-size wine refrigerator, fridge and freezer drawer, and an under-counter ice maker. Floor-to-ceiling glass fills the home with natural light and frames expansive Bay views, complemented by a sleek interior gas fireplace. Each bedroom offers a private balcony and spa-inspired bathrooms with custom cabinetry and quartzite finishes, while the owner’s suite adds serene water views, a hydrotherapy tub, and a custom wardrobe. Outdoors, the home becomes a private waterfront resort with an alfresco culinary area featuring roll-down screens, a custom pool with underwater seating, a fire pit, and low-maintenance artificial turf surrounded by native palms. A brand-new seawall lines the shoreline, leading to a high-performance dock with two boat lifts—15,000 lbs and 6,000 lbs. The home is connected to natural gas, enhancing efficiency and performance throughout. A high-end designer furniture package can be negotiated or purchased separately, allowing for a turnkey transition into one of Fort Myers Beach’s most remarkable custom residences.

441 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach

Start Your Search